The mother of all plotholes
Here’s something that’s been bugging me for a while, and so far nobody has provided a satisfying answer. It concerns Lord Of The Rings, more specifically Return Of The King. First of all, I love these movies. Truly epic masterpieces. I have attempted to read the books several times, but every time I stopped reading for some reason and by the time I picked it up again, I lost track of the story. I hope to finish all books one day, because there’s a lot of stuff in there that didn’t make it into the movies.
But here’s what’s been bugging me. They have to take the ring into Mordor and throw it into the lava in Mount Doom. The problem is, Mordor is surrounded by mountains and swarming with orcs. Good thing, because without all that it would have been a pretty boring journey (probably consisting of Sam asking Frodo “Are we there yet?” every five minutes). Whe they finally make it and manage to destroy the ring, Mount Doom erupts and they are trapped on a rock, surrounded by lava. Luckily, they are rescued by Gandalf who comes to their aid on a huge bird.
So that’s where the plothole comes into play. Gandalf can apparently get help from giant birds; he used them once to escape from Saruman’s tower. But why the hell didn’t they just use these freaking birds to get to Mordor? Just hop on one of them, fly to Mordor, drop the ring into the crater and voila, bye bye evil lurking presence of the Dark Lord. Since I haven’t read the books yet it might end differently there (if it does, don’t tell me!), but at least in the movies, it’s a gigantic, unforgivable mistake. Peter Jackson could at least have thought of a different escape route or explained why they didn’t take the birds in the first place.
Can someone answer this for me? Why didn’t they take the birds to get the ring into Mordor? Was the “Eye of Sauron” on his tower equipped with some sort of laser beam to shoot down the birds? Did the orcs have surface-to-air missiles (and don’t tell me they would have shot down the birds with bows and arrows, birds of that size could easily fly high enough to be out of range; besides, Gandalf didn’t seem to have any trouble escaping Saruman’s tower, even though it was surrouded by Orcs)?
